Monday, August 13, 2007

Absolute Linux 12.0.2 Review


According to Absolute website "Assembled to make installation and maintenance of Slackware easier. Built for speed, stability, security, ease of use and development (if you are so inclined.) I am as confident in it's stability as a stock Slackware box -- and that is saying something"

Test Machine
The test machine that I am using is an AMD Athlon 2600+ XP, 1 Gig RAM, 64 Meg ATI 7200 with 15" LCD capable of 1024x768@75Hz

Booting
Absolute does not come with a live cd mechanism. You have to wait for full installation to complete in order to see what an absolute linux machine looks like.

Installation
The installation process is standard ncurses based installer created by Slackware. You can add a swap partition and root partition. The installer allows you to select amongst reiserfs, ext3 and xfs file systems. It also recognizes any NTFS/FAT partitions found on the machine and allows you to configure them. User is prompted for installation mechanisms; "Install from Absolute CD/DVD is the default option". One interesting point to note is that Absolute comes only with single CD install media but it lists DVD media as well.

Once the installation method is selected, the installation starts. It takes approximately 15 minutes to install Absolute on my machine. Thereafter the modem configuration screen is displayed. The user can configure LILO as the boot loader. I prefer Grub though, but there is no such option.

The next screen allows the user to configure the mouse which is followed by the Network configuration. Then the user can select which services to start when the system boots. Console font configuration, timezone configuration follow. The last step is to set a root password.

There is no initial user configuration allowed by the installer, so the user has to login as root on first startup. During this Absolute tries to configure XServer. The resultant xorg.conf was completely screwed up; it did dot detect the frequencies correctly.Moreover, there is no DefaultDepth specified and for the Depths specified, Modes configuration is missing.

The default run level is 3; thus you land onto command prompt. I don't get this; what's the point of configuring X if you are not providing it as default login. Also, Absolute is supposed to be a desktop oriented distribution, they why the default run level 3 instead of 4.

Aesthetics
In this department I will say that Absolute is just bad taste. The look and feel resembles that of windows 95. I can see some of user interface blunders. There are two panels configured by default, both are having the same size and almost the same color.The second one floats over the first one; confusing the user. (In the screen shots I have placed one of the panels on the top)

Applications
The applications found in absolute are limited and suited for a single person only. There are two different file browsers, Rox and Alt. There are a couple of educational applications and some dedicated to configuration tools.

Internet applications are limited to Firefox, gFTP, sylpheed. ktorrent, pidgin and putty. Some games are also thrown in. Graphics applications include gimp, screenshot, monitor calibration, color selector etc. There is a video player, an audio player and a sound controller. Nedit, Abiword, vim editors are available. pAgenda Calendar is also available as calendar application. QtCrust, HTML Page and pyCrust are availbale for development.

Absolute linux uses XPKGTOOL as a front end for installing applications.

Multimedia
I was able to play MP3 and windows media files with absolute linux.

Eye Candy
Absolute linux is meant to be installed on low end older machines, thus ruling out the possiblity of eye candy.

Recommendations
Absolute needs to evolve, it needs to have a community and thus become less specific and more generic.

Conclusion
I seriously do not understand the need or vision for Absolute linux. It does not provide anything extra over Slackware. Slackware offers icewm, fluxbox, kde and some other window managers to be selected during installation process.

Absolute is based on slackware and thus started with version 12; highest version number existing for any distribution. But wait a second, where are version 1 to 11?

Making a distribution is really easy now-a-days, pick a package manger, pick up a list of open source applications to install, create custom packages and burn them on a disk. But the soul of any distribution is the vision. What do you want to acomplish with your distribution. And in my opinion absolute linux is absolutely missing the soul.

AddThis Social Bookmark Button

8 comments :

Anonymous said...

~「朵語‧,最一件事,就。好,你西光的交替之中瀟灑獨行。

Anonymous said...

runescape money site is selling runescape gold and runescape gold
item,offering runescape money gp.runescape money,runescape gold and runescape gold
2 Gold are collected

美麗資訊攻略站 said...

<14>新彩整形,不孕症達人,心安居家看護,簡善琳瑜珈,畯富包車旅遊,三泰保健食品,104法拍屋,信律隔熱紙,禾雅堂乳酪蛋糕,潘朵拉日韓服飾,優質行動網,網路行銷,旅遊達人,旅遊資訊,日光花園,瑜珈天地,小蝸牛,潘朵拉服飾,建炳整形,信律隔熱紙,優質網,新彩整形,建炳整形,郭鴻璋婦產科,網路行銷,隔熱專家,actionone,機票旅遊,汽車旅館天地,日光花園,瑜珈天地,法拍屋達人,清潔達人,行動百分百,優質天地,百分百,aoone,actionone,首頁科技,新彩整形,建炳整形,嘉俞瑜珈,actionone,優質蛋糕,創意蛋糕,彌月蛋糕,美味蛋糕,彌月送禮,彌月禮盒,彌月禮,彌月,禾雅堂彌月蛋糕,乳酪蛋糕,原味蛋糕,日式抹茶蛋糕,松子蛋糕,黑糖蛋糕,蔓越莓蛋糕,芒果蛋糕,巧克力蛋糕,乳酪,禾雅堂乳酪,禾雅堂乳酪蛋糕,巧克力,巧克力蛋糕,禾雅堂巧克力蛋糕,禾雅堂巧克力,手工巧克力,黑巧克力,巧克力醬,巧克力製作

Wholesale Womens Clothing said...

It is very interesting article and quite impressive and more informative and looking forward to read such article. I would love some feedback on my site beach coverup when you got time

garden supply wholesalers said...

Since I’m new to blogging, these articles are greatly appreciated; very useful and informative blog and every body must visit this blog. Feel free to check out my site globe stationary accessories when you got time.

discount watches said...

Thanks for taking the time to discuss this, I feel strongly about it and love learning more on this topic. If possible, as you gain expertise, would you mind updating your blog with more information? It is extremely helpful for me.
cheap bridemaid dresses
mother of the bride dresses
cheap flower girl dresses
cheap wedding dresses
replica watches
luxury watches

Anonymous said...

酒店經紀酒店打工 酒店工作酒店上班 酒店兼差 酒店兼職 打工兼差 打工兼職台北酒店 酒店應徵 禮服酒店 酒店經紀 打工兼差

Amy C said...

Thank you for shaaring this